Ownership How A Rusted Car Compares To A New One In A Crash Test

15:21  23 april  2018
15:21  23 april  2018 Source:   jalopnik.com

Video Compares the Kia Forte to…a Lamborghini Aventador

  Video Compares the Kia Forte to…a Lamborghini Aventador Why do you need 700 hp when you can have wireless charging?Normally, consumers would cross-shop the new Kia Forte with rivals including the Honda Civic, Ford Focus, or Toyota Corolla. But in a new video, Kia pits its compact sedan against a much more aspirational car, to put it mildly. And the results aren't disastrous as you'd expect.

The rusty VW Golf didn’t see much of a change compared to its crash test rating when new , with its EuroNCAP score dropping only slightly from 33 points to 32. How bad is it? We don’t really know based on this testing , but this may be just one more reason you should work to keep rust off your car .

This crash test is designed to establish how much a sample component deforms under a defined bending "We managed to halve the deflection of a locally laser reinforced pipe profile compared to the I had an optional electronic anti- rust module installed in my car purchased new in 2009 which.

a close up of a car© Screenshot: Villaägarnas Riksförbund (YouTube)

A Swedish insurance company partnered with a Swedish homeowner’s organization to commission crash tests of a rusted Mazda6 wagon and a rusted Volkswagen Golf to see how badly the corrosion compromised the cars’ structural integrity. Here’s what the study found.

Swedish insurance company Folksam teamed up Villaägarnas Riksförbund, a Swedish organization that “promote[s] and protect[s] the interest of homeowners,” to commission the crash tests of two rusty cars at the Thatcham Research Centre in the United Kingdom.

According to Villaägarnas’ press release, Folksam says the results indicate that one of the cars saw a 20 percent higher risk of death in an accident when compared with a rust-free, new model. But, while this may sound conclusive, the full study implies that there’s a lot of uncertainty associated with rust’s affect on the car’s performance.

Driving Test Abruptly Ends When Student Crashes Into Building

  Driving Test Abruptly Ends When Student Crashes Into Building We're guessing that's an automatic fail.Spring is literally in the air for those of us in the Northern Hemisphere, and with the first springtime weekend nearly upon us, here’s a gentle reminder that not everyone on the street is as adept at driving as we all aspire to be. That’s especially true for the younger generation taking those exciting-but-frightening first steps into the motorized world. Every single one of us has a story of terror from our early days behind the wheel, but hopefully none of them involve crashing through a building.

How A Rusted Car Compares To A New One In A Crash Test . Go to permalink. A Swedish insurance company partnered with a Swedish homeowner’s organization to commission crash tests of a rusted Mazda6 wagon and a rusted Volkswagen Golf to see how badly the corrosion compromised

I missed cars and coffee again. Need to find something that caters better to my weekend schedule. JalopnikVerified account @Jalopnik. How a rusted car compares to a new one in a crash test http Someone mangled the radiator support in the Buick but I found a new one for 0 online.

The cars used in the test were a first generation Mazda6 (representing 2003 to 2008 model years) and a fifth generation VW Golf (representing 2004 to 2008 model years), both of which were put through NCAP frontal and side crash tests so the results could be compared to the official NCAP tests conducted when the cars were new.

As shown in the video at the end of the article, those tests included a 40 mph frontal offset crash test with a deformable barrier and a 31 mph side impact from a moving deformable barrier.

a car parked on the side of a building© Screenshot: Villaägarnas Riksförbund (YouTube)

The rusty VW Golf didn’t see much of a change compared to its crash test rating when new, with its EuroNCAP score dropping only slightly from 33 points to 32. But the Mazda 6—a vehicle known to have rust issues—saw a drop from 26 to 18 points, bringing it down from a weak four star rating to a weak three, Villaägarnas Riksförbund says. The organization summarizes the rusty 6's crash results, saying:

Ford Escape biffs IIHS crash test as airbag fails to deploy

  Ford Escape biffs IIHS crash test as airbag fails to deploy The Insurance Institute's latest round of crash testing evaluated 7 different small SUVs, including the BMW X1, Chevy Equinox, Jeep Compass and Mitsubishi Outlander Sport."Both the Outlander Sport and Escape allowed too much intrusion into the occupant compartment on the right side," the Institute said in a statement, rating the Escape's overall performance as "Poor" and the Mitsubishi's as "Marginal.

As the tests show, both cars received a lower rating in comparison to when new . “When the Mazda 6 was tested in the frontal test , the car was deformed so that the driver’s seat ended Watch the videos below to compare how the rusted crash tests fared in comparison with original Euro NCAP’s tests .

Shocking new car vs old car crash test mat vlogs. 2012 honda cr-v driver-side small overlap iihs crash test . 2017 toyota c-hr - crash test . How to repair rust on your car without welding (no special tools needed). 2017 mercedes e-class crash test - better than 5 stars.

...According to Folksam, for Mazda 6 this is 20 per cent higher risk of being killed in a real accident.

It is not certain that another used Mazda 6 with serious rust damage had behaved just like in our crash. However, depending on where the rust is sitting, other negative and uncontrolled crosstalk effects could occur, compared to when the car was new. Due to the rust, the car is not deformed as intended and the ability to catch collision is deteriorated.

Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)© Provided by Univision Interactive Media, Inc. Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)

Okay, so a 20 percent higher risk of death in a real crash test; that’s pretty straightforward, right? Rust is very bad for a vehicle’s crash test performance, one might deduce. Well, reading through the details of the study suggests that the results of this test are highly inconclusive.

The lower front crash rails, shown above, are very rusty, however, according to researchers, the corrosion likely did not affect results in the frontal offset test, with the report stating:

Google Minivan In 'Autonomous Mode' Involved In Crash In Arizona

  Google Minivan In 'Autonomous Mode' Involved In Crash In Arizona A self-driving minivan belonging to Google’s self-driving car unit, Waymo, was involved in a crash in Chandler Arizona on Friday. The aftermath looks brutal. We don’t know a whole bunch about the conditions surrounding this crash, but we do know from a Chandler Police Department statement provided by spokesperson Seth Tyler that Waymo’s Chrysler Pacifica was in “autonomous mode” during the crash, and that it doesn’t appear to have been the primary cause the impact.“We are currently investigating a minor injury collision involving two vehicles, one of which is a Waymo autonomous vehicle,” the statement reads.

New tests conducted by Thatcham Research have highlighted the dangers of driving vehicles corroded by rust . The results demonstrate how chassis rust can impact a vehicle's crash performance, which is a significant risk for drivers of older cars .

Crash testing older cars . The cars included the Mazda 6 and Volkswagen Golf. Both videos reveal that the old, rusted cars couldn’t match the crash safety levels they once did when they were new . The Mazda 6, which you can see immediately below, had a noticeable amount of change when compared

From Figure 2 and 3 the extent of the rust is very severe; however, it does not appear to have greatly affected the structure of the lower chassis leg. The welds on the left image have not failed despite being surrounded in rust...This level of deformation of the front chassis leg is to be expected from the ODB impact, but without any original 2003 test images it is impossible to say with certainty if this vehicle reacted differently.

Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)© Provided by Univision Interactive Media, Inc. Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)

The unibody rails, too, despite significant corrosion, may not have performed any differently than they would have without the rust, with the report writing:

The point of failure is the spot welds between the two sections. Once these spot welds failed, the floor section was able to greatly deform into the passenger compartment. It was noted in the original 2003 Euro NCAP Test that the footwell of the vehicle ruptured, and without original test images it is difficult to say what the extent of this deformation was.

Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)© Provided by Univision Interactive Media, Inc. Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)

Even in the side impact, all the rust in the side sills may not have been such a huge detriment, with the study writing:

Uber Shuts Down Autonomous Vehicle Program in Arizona

  Uber Shuts Down Autonomous Vehicle Program in Arizona Will continue developing self-driving tech elsewhereAs we previously reported, one of Uber's autonomous Volvo XC90 test vehicles struck and killed 49-year-old Elaine Herzberg, who was walking her bicycle across the road. A video of the March 18 accident seemed to show the car did not react to the pedestrian, and the safety operator behind the wheel was looking down just before the crash. Uber halted all autonomous testing immediately following the accident, and not long after that Arizona governor Doug Ducey suspended Uber's license to test self-driving cars in the state indefinitely.

How A Rusted Car Compares To A New One In A Crash Test . A Swedish insurance company partnered with a Swedish homeowner’s organization to commission crash tests of a rusted Mazda6 wagon and a rusted Volkswagen Golf to see how badly the corrosion compromised the cars ’

Thatcham Research discovered significant chassis rust can lead to a lower Euro NCAP score, making cars more dangerous. That is the finding from the world’s first crash test on used cars conducted under similar criteria to Euro NCAP tests on new models.

Figure 10 shows the deformation of the sill after the MDB impact. The footwell can be seen to have buckled a large amount in the impact, which most likely caused the additional compression of the ribs in the dummy. Again it is difficult to say whether the corrosion caused additional collapse of the sill and B-pillar without knowledge of the original 2003 impact.

a screenshot of a cell phone: Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)© Provided by Univision Interactive Media, Inc. Thatcham Research (Villaagarna)

In the end, despite headlines like “Major deterioration of crash safety for Mazda 6" (translated from Swedish) in the Villaägarnas Riksförbund press release, the results—as with most things in life—appear to be rather nuanced.

Thatcham Research Centre’s conclusion section begins by saying:

Without the original footage and full inspection report it is difficult to say with certainty about the effect of the condition of the vehicle on it’s safety performance.

But it does go on saying that, based on the modifiers shown in the above plot—particularly the ones related to the head bottoming out on the steering wheel, body shell integrity and footwell rupture—it appears that the rusty car did indeed perform worse than the Mazda 6 that was tested in 2003.

“It is the opinion of the author that the corrosion of the vehicles did negatively affect the safety performance of these tests,” the conclusion states, though the report finishes by admitting the results aren’t quite conclusive:

However, the extent of this negative affect is not as severe as expected. Without modifiers, the scores between the 2003 and 2018 tests are very comparable, and only after the application of modifiers do the results begin to differ..Without a much deeper analysis of the structure of the crashed vehicles, would you be able to confidently comment upon the affect of the corrosion onto the crash performance of the structure of the vehicle.

So basically, rust is—as one might intuitively think—most likely bad for the crash structure of an automobile. How bad is it? We don’t really know based on this testing, but it’s just one more reason you should work to keep rust off your car.


Follow MSN Autos on Facebook and Twitter

Ford Expedition Earns Five-star Safety Rating .
The all-new 2018 Ford Expedition has earned the U.S. government’s highest possible crash test rating of five stars from the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, making this full-size SUV a leader in safety. Expedition’s improved performance is powered by an average weight savings of up to 325 lb through the use of high-strength, military-grade, aluminum alloy in the body, which lowers the vehicle’s center of gravity for enhanced stability and driving dynamics.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!