Canada OSPCA search and seizure powers being challenged in court today

12:56  16 may  2018
12:56  16 may  2018 Source:   cbc.ca

Ken Jeong Jumps Off Stage to Help Woman Having Seizure During His Stand-Up Set

  Ken Jeong Jumps Off Stage to Help Woman Having Seizure During His Stand-Up Set The actor, who is also a licensed doctor, saved the day when he provided emergency medical assistance to a woman in the audience during his comedy set in Arizona on Saturday.The 48-year-old actor -- best known for playing crazy Spanish teacher Ben Chang on Community and insane naked mobster Mr. Chow in The Hangover -- proved he's got much more in common with his character from his short-lived sitcom Dr. Ken when he jumped into action to save a woman with a medical emergency during a stand-up set over the weekend.

remove ospca charitable and police powers of ospca . Most recently, 21 dogs seized in an alleged fighting ring in Chatham, Ontario, are being held by the OSPCA , who has applied to the courts for permission to kill them.

Start a petition. Membership. Search . Return all dogs seized by OSPCA from the Ashworth Farm; Drop all fees and costs Strip the powers from Nicol Driscoll, Lynn Michaud and Jennifer Bluhm; Investigate all OSPCA agents involved in the unwarranted seizure .

a person holding a bag: Officers of the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (OSPCA) are granted police powers to enforce animal cruelty laws, but an eastern Ontario man is going to court to argue that it's unconstitutional.© Ontario SPCA Officers of the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (OSPCA) are granted police powers to enforce animal cruelty laws, but an eastern Ontario man is going to court to argue that it's unconstitutional.

An eastern Ontario man is going to court today, alleging the search and seizure powers granted to the Ontario Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals (OSPCA) violate the Charter rights of Ontarians.

Jeffrey Bogaerts — a paralegal and member of the Ontario Landowners Association — is scheduled to appear in a Perth, Ont., courtroom Wednesday to challenge the powers of OSPCA officers, who can enter a private residence without a warrant and seize an animal.

The Canada Revenue Agency's Battle Against Taxpayers Has Just Begun

  The Canada Revenue Agency's Battle Against Taxpayers Has Just Begun As we've come to the end of the first stage of tax filing season for most Canadians, people breathe a sigh of relief that their annual tax nightmare is over. But unfortunately for many, the real ordeal is just getting cued up.Fighting City HallThe Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) can, and does, demand proof of payment by way of invoices and receipts that you must legally keep for six years. It can challenge entitlements that you're within your right to claim. And, CRA has extraordinary powers of seizure without court orders, to ensure that taxpayers who owe money to the government do pay up.

Start a petition. Membership. Search . OSPCA withdraw their plans to obtain approval from the courts to kill any of the remaining dogs OSPCA can not be permitted to continually seize and kill animals with impunity.

In France the police have extensive powers of search and seizure in the case of flagrant offense and when a crime is being committed or has just been committed, but in other instances court authorization is required.

In his application, Bogaerts alleges the powers the private charity is granted under Ontario's OSPCA Act violate the right to life, liberty and security of the person, and that the OSPCA should be subject to provincial scrutiny.

And in what might at first appear to be incongruous, the national animal rights group Animal Justice — an intervener in the court case — agrees with Bogaerts that the OSPCA needs oversight.

a man wearing glasses and smiling at the camera: Lawyer Kurtis Andrews (pictured) is representing Jeffrey Bogaerts, who argues the Charter rights of animal owners in Ontario are being violated by the sweeping enforcement powers granted to the OSPCA.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Lawyer Kurtis Andrews (pictured) is representing Jeffrey Bogaerts, who argues the Charter rights of animal owners in Ontario are being violated by the sweeping enforcement powers granted to the OSPCA.

'The law should be overseen by the government'

Bogaerts declined an interview with CBC News and referred all questions to his lawyer, Kurtis Andrews.

Mike Myers Wants to Do an 'Austin Powers' Movie From Dr. Evil's Perspective (Exclusive)

  Mike Myers Wants to Do an 'Austin Powers' Movie From Dr. Evil's Perspective (Exclusive) The 54-year-old Canadian actor said he's ready for 'Austin Powers 4.'Mike Myers is ready for Austin Powers 4!

The Ashworth's appealed the seizure to the Animal Care Review Board. Those hearings have not been completed yet. It's not new to them. Do a Google search and you will find out for yourself. OSPCA has their own agenda.

Searches and seizures are used to produce evidence for the prosecution of alleged criminals. The police have the power to search and seize , but individuals are protected against Arbitrary, unreasonable police intrusions.

"The enforcement of animal welfare laws should not be delegated to a private organization," Andrews said. "The law should be overseen by the government, so we need to have accountability and transparency in the enforcement of animal welfare laws, like we have for every other law in the province."

OSPCA investigators have police-like powers but aren't subject to Ontario's Police Services Act, which governs police conduct. And since it's not a government agency, the OSPCA is also not subject to freedom-of-information laws and can't be investigated by Ontario's ombudsman.

"That's a problem and we feel that's wrong," Andrews said. "The organization is so insulated from all these safeguards, and that can mean anybody that's affected by them can feel very, very powerless."

Bogaerts not personally involved with OSPCA

Bogaerts has never personally been inspected or investigated by the OSPCA, but two years ago a judge granted him standing to proceed with his case in the public interest despite the Attorney General's attempt to have it dismissed.

Undercover investigation behind animal cruelty charges at Ontario mink farm, U.S.-based rights group says

  Undercover investigation behind animal cruelty charges at Ontario mink farm, U.S.-based rights group says Undercover investigation behind animal cruelty charges at Ontario mink farm, U.S.-based rights group saysThe SPCA on Friday said it had laid 14 charges against a mink ranch in southwestern Ontario, including for neglect and failing to provide medical care. The Provincial Offences Court in Guelph separately verified that the charges had been laid against the owners of Millbank Fur Farm, north of Guelph.

The Ashworths have appealed the seizure and a hearing with the Animal Care Review Board is taking place to decide the fate of the animals. Do not believe the Ontario Liberals can not stop OSPCA if they wanted to. They gave them their power .

The Court ’s short but unanimous opinion helps make sense of how the Fourth Amendment, which protects against unreasonable search and seizure , interacts with the expanding technological powers of the U.S. government. “It doesn’t matter what the context is

Andrews pointed to other people who have come up against OSPCA officers, including Jessica Johnson, a retired postal worker from a small community near Brockville called Lyndhurst.

In 2011, OSPCA agents entered the then-64-year-old part-time dog breeder's home through a bedroom window after she was accused of failing to comply with a court order to fix the teeth of one of her dogs.

Johnson, who was on a fixed income, said she couldn't afford to see dentist herself, let alone one for her pet.

The case garnered widespread attention when high-profile Toronto lawyer Clayton Ruby took on her case, and she eventually lost.

"The court now will decide if the current search and seizure powers are in accordance with the Charter," Andrews said.

a person posing for the camera: Lawyer and Animal Justice executive director Camille Labchuk says the Ontario government, not a private charity, should enforce Ontario animal rights laws.© Provided by Canadian Broadcasting Corporation Lawyer and Animal Justice executive director Camille Labchuk says the Ontario government, not a private charity, should enforce Ontario animal rights laws.

Animal Justice 'neutral' on Charter argument

Last month, a judge granted Animal Justice intervener status in Bogaerts's case to provide context on animal welfare laws.

13 dead horses discovered at Ont. farm where others were found neglected

  13 dead horses discovered at Ont. farm where others were found neglected 13 dead horses discovered at Ont. farm where others were found neglectedThe animals were under the care of David Lee Small, Victoria Small and Jason Leroy Small, who had been renting the barnyard and farmland since September, said landlord Michael Cheung.

That’s the argument being put forward by a pair of “strange bedfellows” who are teaming up on a legal challenge that questions the oversight of, and the powers In its factum to the court , the province argues the OSPCA Act doesn’t violate the charter and that search warrants are required unless the

Start a petition. Membership. Search . Log in or sign up. Strip the powers from Nicol Driscoll, Lynn Michaud and Jennifer Bluhm; Investigate all OSPCA agents involved in the unwarranted seizure . They have no doubt they will will. In a court of law OSPCA won't be able to play the games they did

Lawyer Camille Labchuk, executive director of Animal Justice, said the group is "neutral" on the Charter argument and will ensure the perspective of animals is represented in court.

"In this day and age, when all other public laws are enforced by public bodies, [the fact] that we still leave animal offences to be enforced by a private charity is an anachronism," Labchuk said.

She added it's difficult to say whether OSPCA agents are doing a good job because "there is a vacuum of information."

But while Bogaerts and Andrews say the enforcement of animal cruelty laws is heavy-handed, Labchuk feels enforcement should be strengthened.

"Animals are members of our society and they are not simply objects but thinking and feeling individuals," she said. "It's very critically important for the OSPCA to have broad powers to do searches of people's property due to the unique concept of animals as victims of crime, because they are kept and live their lives typically behind closed doors."

Labchuk doesn't think her group and Bogaerts's case make an odd pairing, considering they agree that public laws should be enforced by the province and not a private charity.

"To me it's very interesting that we see two sides on the opposite end of the spectrum agreeing on this one issue," she said. "It says there is a consensus developing in Ontario that our system needs to change, and we need to bring in, perhaps, an animal police force that is government-run and is accountable and transparent."

The Ontario Superior Court hearing in Perth is scheduled for one day and it's expected the judge will make a final decision at a later date.

Andrews said he hopes the judge will rule that some sections of the OSPCA Act should have "no force or effect," and that if that happens, the government would be given time to rewrite the legislation.

Ontario man alleges family charged with killing 13 horses bilked him of $27K .
A family facing animal cruelty charges for allegedly letting 13 horses die while starving 15 others is now being accused of fraud by the owner of an Ontario farm they were renting, CBC Toronto has learned. Michael Cheung, 45, alleges Speedsport Stables sold him three young horses they didn't own and bilked him of $27,000.

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!