Money When RRSP withdrawals for debt repayment is a bad idea

09:40  02 december  2017
09:40  02 december  2017 Source:   MoneySense

10 ways to save more and pay down your debt

  10 ways to save more and pay down your debt Simple strategies to boost your financial knowledge (and your bank accounts) while easing your debtsIf you’re serious about saving you need to set a goal so you know what you’re saving for. Whether it’s a trip to Japan you hope to take in a few months or saving for retirement, having a very specific goal will help you stay motivated and on track.

If you were contemplating a TFSA withdrawal , with no tax payable, I’d be all for swapping investments for debt repayment . But when it comes to RRSP withdrawals , I think you need to have a low income to make it a viable solution, Tom. You should contribute to RRSPs in high income years, not

Repaying an RRSP withdrawal from the Lifelong Learning Plan doesn't have to start until five years after the first withdrawal . Once your repayments begin, you will have 10 years to pay the money back to your RRSP before the opportunity to replace these funds is lost entirely.

Click here to see more personal finance questions answered.© Used with permission of / © Rogers Media Inc. 2017. Click here to see more personal finance questions answered.

Q: My wife and I currently have a mortgage of $297,000. On top of that we’ve had to dip into our line of credit (unsecured) to the tune of $44,000. I’m trying to determine whether or not it makes sense to withdraw the $44,000 – plus the withholding tax – from my RRSP.

I currently participate in a DB pension and am in a fairly safe/steady employment position. My RRSP is currently sitting at $150,000 and my salary is approximately $115,000.

Re-financing is going to cost quite a bit and wouldn’t necessarily cover the full debt load.

Congrats, Canadians: You’re world leaders in debt

  Congrats, Canadians: You’re world leaders in debt A new report shows our household credit tally has surpassed Canada’s annual GDP. Have we stopped listening to the warnings?

Myth #1: RRSPs are tax-free: Contributions give you a tax refund of up to 40 per cent, depending on your tax bracket. But many people forget that you repay the tax when you draw down the money. If you dip into your RRSP (generally a bad idea ) before you turn 71, here’s what happens

your registered retirement savings plan ( RRSP ), the. C o nditi o n N o . 1 . However, an withdrawing the amount from your RRSP . exception to this rule is when the withdrawals are. This exception does not apply if the repayment was part of a series of loans and repayments .

—Tom

A: I don’t want to be one of those judgemental financial experts who tells you that if you have had to dip into your line of credit to the tune of $44,000, you’re spending too much money. Life happens and sometimes there are expenses that go beyond our budget. Obviously if you guys are continuing to run up your line of credit balance though, that’s not sustainable forever, Tom. But you know that.

With regards to your RRSP withdrawal plan, I think it’s important to clarify that the withholding tax is not the final tax on your withdrawal. An RRSP withdrawal is fully taxable income and gets added to your other income for the year when determining tax payable on your tax return. Tax already withheld gets credited, but you will owe more tax over and above.

St. Clair College has seen 600 students withdraw since strike ended

  St. Clair College has seen 600 students withdraw since strike ended St. Clair College has seen 600 students withdraw since strike endedThe deadline for withdrawing and receiving a full refund is Dec. 5.

Experts warn that plunging deep in debt with an RRSP loan to max out their contribution room can be a very bad idea . Here's how to kick-start your RRSP . TORONTO — When Patrick French was about 18 years old, he got a hot tip about a gold mining stock.

And if you can earn a higher rate of return on your RRSPs than your mortgage interest rate over the long run, this helps to reinforce further not taking RRSP withdrawals as a better strategy. I’m all for debt repayment , when it makes sense. Debt repayment may be a priority, Linda, but it shouldn’t

Ask a Planner: Leave your question for Jason Heath »

You have an income of $115,000 and you’re in a pension plan, so I’ll estimate your taxable income at $105,000 after pension and other deductions, Tom. If you want to have $44,000 after tax from your RRSP withdrawal, you will probably need to take a withdrawal of about $80,000 from your RRSP. It could be more or less depending on the province you live in. In Ontario, it would be about $81,000. In Quebec, about $86,000. And in Saskatchewan, only about $76,000.

READ: 10 ways to save more and pay down your debt

In the same way claiming a tax deduction from an RRSP contribution can be great when you have a high income, taking withdrawals when you have a high income can be terribly taxing. So, Tom, you may need to take out nearly twice as much from your RRSP as you need to be left with what you want after-tax.

I suspect your line of credit interest rate could be 6-8% if it is an unsecured line of credit. You may not be able to generate an 8% RRSP return over the long-run, but 4-5% in a balanced portfolio or 6-7% in an aggressive one may not be unrealistic. If you were contemplating a TFSA withdrawal, with no tax payable, I’d be all for swapping investments for debt repayment. But let’s do some quick math on the assumption that you’re an Ontario resident contemplating an RRSP withdrawal.

St. Clair College has seen 600 students withdraw since strike ended

  St. Clair College has seen 600 students withdraw since strike ended St. Clair College has seen 600 students withdraw since strike endedThe deadline for withdrawing and receiving a full refund is Dec. 5.

Surprisingly, 72% of respondents favoured debt repayment over retirement savings . The primary reason cited by the majority of those who preferred debt Figure 1 – Benefit when marginal tax rate is 30% upon contribution and withdrawal ; RRSP / TFSA return = 6%; Rate on Debt = 3%.

My first thought was that it is a very bad idea . Before we start with the scenarios, lets look at some of the basics: RRSP Withdrawals and Withholding tax

You’d need to take a withdrawal of $81,000 from your RRSP to have $44,000 after-tax. Let’s say you are giving up a 4% return on your $81,000 in investments – that’s $3,240 per year. Let’s say your $44,000 line of credit is at 8% interest – that’s $3,520 per year. Not much difference, right? But you’d have to give up $37,000 of RRSP capital in the form of tax to wipe out the line of credit.

MORE: Paying off the line of credit

I think I would be much more inclined in your case to continue to plug away at debt repayment, Tom. If you could consolidate your line of credit into your mortgage, that would be ideal as you could bring your interest rate down. If it means you don’t pay your debt off for longer or even into retirement, you may be better off in the long run by not raiding your RRSP in a high income, high tax year.

Given you have a DB pension, you may have a fairly high income in retirement as well, but likely nowhere near what your income is now. Plus, in the meantime, you will have a bigger RRSP growing more and more over time that you can strategically withdraw in retirement.

Cashing in investments to pay down debt is well worth considering if those investments are non-registered or TFSA investments. But when it comes to RRSP withdrawals, I think you need to have a low income to make it a viable solution, Tom. You should contribute to RRSPs in high income years, not withdraw, unless there is an incredibly extraordinary situation. A bit of unsecured line of credit debt isn’t extraordinary in my opinion.

When you break up a year after buying a condo together

  When you break up a year after buying a condo together Should you let your ex buy you out of a mortgage—especially when you live in Vancouver?0000

Whether it’s paying down debt , saving for a down payment , funding your children’s education or The federal government creates the RRSP , originally called a “ registered retirement annuity”. Spousal RRSPs are introduced so that withdrawals can be taxed in the hands of the lower-earning spouse.

debitcreditscore.com. Coming soon. repay your debt is to.

Ask a Planner: Leave your question for Jason Heath »

Jason Heath is a fee-only, advice-only Certified Financial Planner (CFP) at Objective Financial Partners Inc. in Toronto, Ontario. He does not sell any financial products whatsoever.

MORE FROM A TAX EXPERT:

  • How you’re taxed when selling a business to family
  • How much tax do I owe on the sale of collectable wines at auction?
  • Owning Canadian stocks as a U.S. resident
  • Will gifting a home avoid U.S. capital gains tax?
  • Pay less tax on rental properties
  • What taxes do my LIRA beneficiaries have to pay?
  • Paying taxes on an inheritance
  • How can my stock losses be used to lower taxes?


Canadian households lead the world in terms of debt: OECD .
Canadian households borrow more than people in any other OECD country, and house prices are at least 50 per cent overpriced than they should be based on the rental market, the group says in a new report.AMZN

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!