Money Guaranteed income is a no-brainer—just don’t call it an annuity

12:36  17 may  2018
12:36  17 may  2018 Source:

Why don’t people who can’t afford housing just move where it’s cheaper?

  Why don’t people who can’t afford housing just move where it’s cheaper? California is in fact losing population to domestic migration, but for many people, the calculation is more about social networks than economics.SAN FRANCISCO — Many San Francisco renters I met while reporting an article on affordable housing lotteries had responded to the region’s housing crisis by putting up with great discomfort: They crammed in with family; they split apartments with strangers. Some even lived out of their cars.

This so- called annuity puzzle has baffled academics, policymakers and As an investment, an annuity just doesn' t stack up. But if your objective is to ensure enough money to live on no matter how long you live -- think consumption instead of accumulation -- then an annuity is a no - brainer .

This one is kind of a no - brainer . An annuity where the income will vary based on the performance of some portfolio (also called a variable annuity with a guaranteed lifetime withdrawal benefit).

  Guaranteed income is a no-brainer—just don’t call it an annuity © Used with permission of / © Rogers Media Inc. 2018.

Those near or in retirement really like the idea of receiving a Guaranteed Lifetime Income (GLI), a study released Tuesday says. But tell them this is the same as an old-fashioned life annuity, and suddenly many lose interest.

Quotes in the article

Great-West Lifeco Inc


Should I raid my RRSP to pay off my line of credit?

  Should I raid my RRSP to pay off my line of credit? It’s tempting to cash out RRSPs but watch out for the tax biteI currently participate in a DB pension and am in a fairly safe/steady employment position. My RRSP is currently sitting at $150,000 and my salary is approximately $115,000.

Lifetime annuities are designed to give you peace of mind and a guaranteed income for life, no matter how the financial markets perform. Remember, if you want help at any stage, just call us on the number below. Step 1. Apply for an annuity .

If this question seems a no - brainer , welcome to the club. Economists call this the “ annuity puzzle.” Using standard assumptions, economists have shown that buyers of annuities are assured more annual income for the rest of their lives, compared with people who self-manage their portfolios.

S&P/TSX Composite


S&P/TSX Venture Composite


S&P TSX 60



That’s a pity because, as this column has long argued, there is a growing need for a Guaranteed Lifetime Income, particularly as employer-sponsored defined benefit pensions fall by the wayside.

The prevailing bias against annuities is in evidence again, with the results of a new 2018 Canadian Guaranteed Lifetime Income Study, conducted by Greenwald & Associates and CANNEX for two Canadian insurance companies.

In the study, almost half of the subject (aged 55 to 75) cited concerns like inflation, low interest rates and stock market volatility when it comes to having enough money in retirement. Any yet the study confirmed that annuities, which can help resolve those challenges, remain poorly understood—both for their benefits as well as their drawbacks.

No more government cash for Ontario companies, Doug Ford says

  No more government cash for Ontario companies, Doug Ford says NIAGARA FALLS, ONT. — The honeymoon is over when it comes to companies getting government cash in Ontario, Progressive Conservative Leader Doug Ford said Monday on his way to visit a firm that got millions in federal aid.It’s not fair that some companies enjoy financial assistance from taxpayers while others don’t, Ford added on a campaign swing through wine country in the June 7 election campaign.“Instead of picking winners and losers we’re going to lower business taxes for everyone, we’re going to stabilize business hydro rates, we’re going to cut red tape and we’re going to bring good jobs back home,” he said on a hotel terrace overlooking the horseshoe falls.

A guaranteed annuity backed by TIAA’s claims-paying ability, TIAA Traditional guarantees your Having other accounts at Fidelity, my switch seemed to be a no - brainer . I don ’ t know about just “buying” an annuity through TIAA-CREF, that is not what you do if you are in a retirement plan.

It was called a “mincome” experiment, as in “minimum income .” It was conducted in just a couple of places, including a town of about 12,000 called Dauphin. “The Town With No Poverty: Using Health Administration Data To Revisit Outcomes of a Canadian Guaranteed Annual Income Field

READ: Why Ottawa needs to push for tontine-type annuities

CANNEX and Greenwald found similar perceptions of the positives and negatives of annuity-type products on both sides of the Canada-U.S. border. Two-thirds of respondents like the peace of mind and longevity protection of GLI, which makes it easier to budget. But the top negatives are also familiar: having to hand over capital to an insurance company, the possibility of dying early and not getting all your money back (or be able to pass on to your heirs), high costs and too many terms and conditions.

Whatever you call it, the percentage of Canadians who value some kind of guaranteed income is rising sharply.  The number of those who see it as a “highly valuable” supplement to government retirement sources like CPP and OAS has jumped from 60% in 2015 to 80% today.

Longevity and outliving savings is a particular concern for women, along with not being able to afford long-term care expenses. It’s a fact that women have longer life expectancies, and the online study (commissioned by Great-West Life Assurance and Sun Life Financial) shows their retirement worries are greater as a result:

When an RRSP isn’t worth it

  When an RRSP isn’t worth it Julia has a DB pension and is maxing out her TFSA. Is an RRSP worth it for her?What is your recommendation for next steps? Should I invest in a non-registered account? Or give in to the RRSP option? My goal is to harness the magic of compounding, so I can be successful in later years.

Call 01737 233297 or visit 4 pension aNnuity . Shopping around for a guaranteed income for life. What if I need a larger amount? No problem. With our Pension Annuity you can choose how much you want to receive, although you 10 pension aNnuity . About us. We are Just .

Don ’ t just take IT from us… New York Life and NYLIAC’s surplus is one of the strongest in the industry, acting as a A Lifetime Income Annuity provides retirement income that is guaranteed 6 to last as long as you live, no matter how long that is and no matter how the financial markets perform.

  • The study found 34% of women are highly concerned about not being able to maintain their standard of living once they retire, compared to only 17% of men.
  • Some 37% of females worry about long-term care expenses in old age, versus just 20% of men.
  • Women place more importance on having GLI at all stages of retirement: early, middle and late; and 76% of them think it important that their essential living expenses be covered by a GLI source, versus 64% of men.

The study, conducted in February with 1,003 Canadians with financial assets of at least $100,000 (not counting a home), found only 45% are highly confident they will be able to maintain their standard of living in retirement, assuming a life expectancy of 85.

READ: How to avoid outliving your money

As we have noted in the past, it’s surprising annuities aren’t more popular, given the ongoing decline in private-sector DB pensions and the rise in longevity.

  • The study found a relatively low ownership of income annuities or segregated funds: 19% of women owned them, and 20% of men.
  • Even now, DB pensions are still three times more common across households: 65% of women said they expect to receive some retirement income from an employer DB plan, versus 61% of men.

As leading retirement experts like author Moshe Milevsky have said, capital-appreciation vehicles like RRSPs, group RRSPs or Defined Contribution pensions are no substitute for “real” pensions like DB plans, which provide a guaranteed income for life no matter how long you live.

B.C. Ombudsperson's report shows thousands of welfare recipients unfairly penalized

  B.C. Ombudsperson's report shows thousands of welfare recipients unfairly penalized The B.C. Ombudsperson has a new report on an unlawful policy that unfairly penalized nearly 4,000 people on social assistance over 6 years.TCTZF

If by "need," you mean you would seriously jeopardize your retirement by forgoing an annuity , I'd say the answer is no. Most people don ' t invest any of their Even if you don ' t think you need extra guaranteed income now, you may still want some protection against running out of dough in the future.

And, with just two investment choices — both professionally managed by Fidelity — it ’s easy to invest and get started. If you have any questions about the Fidelity Growth and Guaranteed Income annuity , please call a Fidelity Fidelity Growth and Guaranteed Income ® annuity (Policy Form No.

Those lacking true pensions may attempt to rely on financial assets (RRSPs, TFSAs, non-registered savings) but the onus is on investors to manage their money in the face of the uncertainties of stock markets and low interest rates. The stark reality is that a combination of a very long life, plus perpetual minuscule interest rates, plus stock-market losses, could well mean running out of money before you run out of life.

READ: RRIF or annuity? How about both.

That’s why Milevsky (who has also called for a revival of tontine annuities, as per a recent column in this space), wrote the book Pensionize Your Nestegg. That book, which we have reviewed, argues that those lacking true pensions need to use annuities or their variants to cope with market uncertainties, not to mention the challenge of outliving your money. There’s a good reason annuities have been described as “longevity insurance.”

Some critics of annuities have argued financial advisors aren’t incented to recommend annuities; they typically generate only a one-time commission, while asset-based advisors stand to generate a fee every year a client stays with them (thereby creating a de facto annuity for the advisor, which is ironic). However, the GLI study found that in both countries, one of the top sources of information on GLI products is financial advisors: 24% heard about them from advisors, versus 18% at financial institutions and 15% by news media.

Ontario's Bold Basic Income Experiment Creates High Expectations

  Ontario's Bold Basic Income Experiment Creates High Expectations <p>Sherry Mendowegan has accomplished a lot in the past six months. The mother-of-two bought her first vehicle and graduated with her high school diploma in March.</p>"Next is my college, post-secondary, and then hopefully I get some work," she told HuffPost Canada.

But a ladder also lets them increase their annuity income as their monthly expenses rise. "No matter what else happens to my money, I don ' t have to worry," says Gregory. Some annuities let you boost the annual guaranteed withdrawal amount if your account value increases.

Sounds like a no brainer , right? What that means is that you should only purchase an annuity for the contractual guarantees . QLACs are really just pension type income guarantees that will start at a future date of your choice.

Even so, Great-West Life senior vice president Sam Sivarajan said in a press release that among the 75% of respondents working with advisors, retirement income conversations are still focused on asset withdrawals and investments paying dividends or interest: “The study shows that guaranteed lifetime income products, more often than not, aren’t part of these discussions.”

It’s surprising how the “annuity” label can be a turnoff for retirees who might otherwise benefit from GLI products. The survey found 70% of those who owned GLI products were satisfied and 60% thought them very important to their financial security. But if the GLI product was labelled as an income annuity or segregated fund, 41% became less interested.

  • 41% were unfamiliar with income annuities but 67% had no knowledge of seg funds;
  • by contrast 74% were familiar with GICs, term deposits and Guaranteed Interest Annuities and 73% with mutual funds.

READ: Bruce Sellery answers your retirement questions

In both countries, clients believe financial advisors have a responsibility to discuss GLI: 70% of American respondents thought so, as did 73% of Canadians. And advisors should take heed of this factoid: many felt that failure to at least discuss the GLI option would be a reason to consider changing their advisor!  Even so, while 79% were satisfied with the financial advice they are receiving, only a third had actually had the GLI conversation with their advisor.

To me, GLI is a no-brainer, at least for a portion of your retirement plans: the money you absolutely need to meet monthly living expenses in retirement. By all means, invest money you can afford to lose in the markets and reap the probable, albeit not assured, healthy returns over the long term.

It’s important to eat well and enjoy a few of life’s luxuries in our golden years. But we also need to sleep well: We all need income, we want it for as long as we live and we want it guaranteed. That’s what GLI products should provide. What’s not to like?

Jonathan Chevreau is founder of the Financial Independence Hub, author of Findependence  Day and co-author of Victory Lap Retirement. He can be reached at



  • Are You GIS-Eligible?
  • Finding hidden money
  • Guaranteed income products: Eternal optimists

Woman aiming for $35,000 a year retirement income worries small savings not enough to reach goal .
There are a few things Nancy can do to boost her income, including downsize her house, but reducing spending alone may get her to where she wants to beSituation: Woman, 60, with no company pension and low six-figure savings worries about future income

—   Share news in the SOC. Networks

Topical videos:

This is interesting!